Do Antidepressants Work as Promised?


Note: This is an editorial

Antidepressants – what’s going on?

One out of ten Americans are currently on antidepressants.  That’s just the beginning.  More than 25% of college students at some schools are on them.

Everyone is being given them for all sorts of reasons.  Are they really that effective or safe?  Maybe.  That said, there is a horrible secret.

We don’t know how antidepressants work.  We don’t know if they are safe for long term use.  And finally, we don’t know how well they work, and for what reasons they should be prescribed.

There’s too much money at risk for the big drug companies to bother to answer these questions.

After all, antidepressants are ideal money-makers, $80 billion annually.  They have to be taken daily for months if not years, and it can be impossible to tell if they’re working.  And they have serious side effects, like possibly doubling your risk of committing suicide.

Flawed studies

Everything we know about antidepressants comes from medical studies.  But the studies are really screwed up.

First, who runs the studies?  The drug companies.  What do they have at stake?

Good results mean that they make hundreds of millions of dollars.  Bad results mean they’ve wasted years of research and development.  What do you think happens?

Positive results in the studies are inflated on average 32%.  One analysis of 74 trials covering 12,500 patients showed that 36 studies gave negative results – and a shocking 11 of those were reported as being positive!  And if the negative studies can’t be spun positive, then we simply don’t hear about them.

Studies on antidepressant safety and efficacy are 94% positive – but if negative studies were published, they’d only be 51% positive.  The difference between what we hear and what is actually going is especially big for new drugs like Remeron.

The less time spent testing the drug means the less chance of picking up annoying side effects and saves operating costs.  Because of that, most studies don’t track long term use, and some studies last only a month.

That’s right.  Despite antidepressants being taken for months if not years, most research into them only goes on for a month or two, ignoring long term risks.

Extremely limited research

Millions of people take antidepressants.  By contrast, the studies which confirm their efficacy and safety study at most a thousand patients.

The initial studies for Prozac that approved its use had only a few hundred patients complete the study.

Some quick math.  30 million people have taken Prozac.  Now imagine there’s a serious side effect that occurs in 1/10,000 of the people who use it, and was missed in the initial studies.  That’s 3,000 people.

Antidepressants aren’t benign drugs, far from it.  They can cause thoughts of suicide in up to 4% of children, anger and violence in adults, alongside more mundane issues like nausea, restlessness and sexual dysfunction.

The Serotonin Hypothesis – a myth?

We don’t know how the medications work.  The Serotonin Hypothesis – that reduced levels of serotonin in the brain cause depression – is inaccurate and lacks scientific basis.

Lowering the level of serotonin in the brain doesn’t cause depression.  Increasing its levels directly doesn’t do much, either.  And if low levels of serotonin were to blame for depression, antidepressants wouldn’t take several weeks to work – they would work within days because that’s how fast they raise levels.

To cap it off, antidepressants that don’t target serotonin – like Wellbutrin – work at about the same rate as those that do.  Clearly the serotonin hypothesis is a vast over simplification that’s convenient for the drug companies.

Use in bipolar?

Antidepressants are very heavily used in patients with bipolar disorder.  Unfortunately, the data seems to be at best only moderately in support of such use, and there are no antidepressants approved for use in Bipolar (July 2008).

The STEP-BD, Systemic Treatment Enhancement Program for Bipolar Disorder, a study run by the National Institute of Mental Health, seems to show that antidepressants are only as effective as placebo for bipolar depression.

And while antidepressants aren’t much better than placebo for bipolar patients, they may exacerbate mood cycling.

Use for depression

A similar major study of antidepressant efficacy for regular depression, STAR*D, showed similarly lackluster results.

STAR*D’s data is open to interpretation, but at the least indicates that antidepressants are not as effective as thought.  About only 50% of patients experienced improvement initially, and over a year span efficacy was only about 25%.

For the vast majority of uses, antidepressants may work only as well as placebo, or a sugar pill.  Placebos, after all, show about the same 25% efficacy.  Due to the psychological nature of depression, the placebo effect absolutely must be monitored for.


Antidepressants do help some people, and do save lives.  A black-box warning in 2003 which sharply reduced their use may be linked to a significant increase in teen suicides.

But they are also huge money makers with highly inflated efficacy rates, and should not be as heavily prescribed as they are.  In many populations, they are no more effective than placebo, but unlike placebo have significant side effects.

Their use in Bipolar patients should be carefully examined.

You might like:

10 Ideas for Treatment Resistant Depression

Agomelatine: A New Treatment for Depression

50 Ways to Make Friends


Why antidepressants are not antidepressants: STEP-BD, STAR*D, and the return of neurotic depression
Effectiveness of antidepressants: an evidence myth constructed from a thousand randomized trials?
Serotonin and Depression: A Disconnect between the Advertisements and the Scientific Literature
The Shocking Truth – Boston Magazine

Depression Help – No Drugs

Natural Depression Relief

HCF Happy, Calm & Focused - The Brain Supplement America Loves

12 thoughts on “Do Antidepressants Work as Promised?

  1. I have tried almost every antidepressant known to mankind and none of them have worked for me. I’ve spent a ton of money trying to take medicine to make myself feel better. The main reason is because I cry for no reason. I do believe that people with depression are very creative which is good but it’s not good for tears to start rolling down your face at work or in front of your children. People say, “chin-up, pray it away, will it away, exercise more, you’re only as happy as you make yourself.” If it were only that easy. They don’t understand that if I could do that I most certainly would. I really don’t know what the answer is but wanted to leave a comment because I’m sure there are other people in this world who are in the same boat as me. I also want to say never, never, never give up – you’re here for a reason:)

  2. Thank God someone besides myself is finally figuring this out! I have been having this argument with family members and members of the medical community(physicians and nurses) for over 25 years. They started pushing prozac back then because there was no correct diagnosis for all of these symptoms and it is pretty much still the same. If we all do not act and feel the same as the majority of citizens do- then we are considered depressed and need to take a pill! How ridiculous is that! This country would not be what it is today if this idea would have been in effect 200 years ago. Just think if antidepressants would have been available back then how many wonderful inventions would never have been followed through with because all of these “inventors” that became despondent, after a slight failure, would have been put on “medication” before they acheived major success!! I am pretty sure I would not be typing this on a computer, using electricity and the internet to state my opinion on this matter. We need to learn to accept the fact that there is NO PILL that will make or keep us happy. Anti depressants might take the reality of your life away for awhile but eventually reality will return and you have to accept that life does not usually turn out the way we have it planned. Then all you can do is make the best of “the hand you were dealt” (as my daddy always said) by trying to live as good a life as possible by setting some goals, working hard to achieve them and loving your family,friends, and neighbors. Then hopefully we will leave our future generations to do the same.

  3. Thanks, Ingrid! Antidepressants are real life savers for some people, but, again, because of their money making potential have become too highly prescribed.

  4. Wow, you have a great blog going on here.. just read a lot of stuff that I did not know before :|

    I’m happy to be fortunate enough not to be on any sorts of antidepressants, .. well okay.. only one.. chocolate :D

    Keep on writing, this is a lot of help for many people,


Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *